What "G-d's Chosen People" Actually Means

[June 2026]

In conversations about Israel and Palestine, one claim keeps popping up like a bad penny: that Jews think we're G-d's chosen people, so that gives us some kind of divine right to occupy land and treat Palestinians like shit. As a Jew who is not a Zionist, and who supports a free Palestine, I get pissed off every time I see it. It lumps all Jews together, paints us with the same ugly brush, and turns what should be sharp political critique into something that smells like old-school antisemitism. 

Criticism of Israel's policies and actions isn't inherently antisemitic. Plenty of Jews, including me, call out the occupation, the violence, and the systemic problems without hesitation. But when people start "noticing" patterns about "Jewish dishonesty" or how we supposedly favor our own over Gentiles because of some chosen status, that's where it crosses into libel. Antisemitism has gotten way too comfortable online lately, and this particular trope fuels it.

​So let's cut through the garbage. This essay lays out what "G-d's chosen people" actually means from someone who lives it, not from outsiders projecting their assumptions or from the loudest fringes. 

_____

No, It Does Not Mean Jewish Supremacy

Look, full disclosure right up front: there are ultra-Orthodox communities where some rabbis teach that Gentiles don't have souls or that Jews sit on a higher spiritual rung. There is Kahanism, an ultra-nationalist sect that supports ethnic cleansing and violence, among other things.

But they represent a small, insular slice of Jewish life. The overwhelming majority of Jews, especially in the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom, lean liberal, often secular, and view those ultra-Orthodox teachings as fringe at best, and think Itamar Ben-Gvir and his Kahanist ilk are nuts and a disgrace. It's similar to how fundamentalist Christians have become the loud default image of Christianity in American culture over the last couple decades, except that unlike fundies now compromising a majority of Christians in the US, ultra-Orthodox Jews are a minority of Jews. Most people get the "not all Christians" nuance when it comes to Christians. Jews deserve the same.

My two best friends are Gentiles. I don't walk around thinking Jews are inherently better than anyone else. People are people. We bleed the same, laugh at the same dumb jokes, and fuck up in the same ordinary human ways. The Torah itself drives this home. It repeatedly commands kindness and respect toward others, especially foreigners living among us. In the ancient context, those foreigners were basically non-Jews. The text doesn't leave room for treating outsiders like lesser beings. It insists on justice, on not oppressing the stranger, because we ourselves were strangers in Egypt. That memory of vulnerability is baked into the tradition.

Living this out means rejecting any supremacy nonsense. I have zero interest in ranking souls or claiming cosmic VIP status. The idea that Jewish identity requires looking down on everyone else doesn't match the reality of how most of us navigate the world. We argue, we disagree, we contain multitudes, just like any other group. Painting all Jews as supremacists because a minority holds extreme views is lazy and dishonest. It ignores the lived experience of liberal, secular, and progressive Jews who make up a huge chunk of the community, especially in the diaspora.

_____

Judaism Is Not Claiming It's the One True Path to Avoid Hell

Another common distortion is that Jews believe Judaism is the only true religion and everyone else is doomed to hell. Sorry, but that's the playbook of born-again Christians, not us. Jewish thinking on the afterlife looks nothing like the fire-and-brimstone version many grew up hearing. We don't have a straightforward hell where bad people burn forever. At worst, the truly monstrous figures, like Hitler, might have their names erased from memory. Others who screwed up badly without making teshuvah (amends and self-improvement) might spend up to eleven months in a kind of astral rehab, working through their shit before moving on. It's corrective, not eternal torture.

Most non-Orthodox Jews embrace religious plurality. We kind of have to in the diaspora. Living as a minority in diverse societies makes it practical, but it also runs deeper than that. Many of us are in interfaith relationships.

Judaism doesn't demand that you become Jewish to be a good person or to have a solid relationship with the divine. Some of the best humans I've ever met come from completely different backgrounds. During a rough stretch in the 2010s when I was dealing with a stalker (pre-Spiced, different bully), a Hindu friend stepped up with real sympathy, free legal advice, and help connecting me with a lawyer. That kindness meant everything. In the Silmarillion fandom, one of the few people who showed me genuine decency was a Christian woman in Germany. She eventually distanced herself from Spiced, the Tolkien fandom bully who targeted me. My roommate and best friend is agnostic and calls herself Jew-adjacent after sharing Shabbat dinners and Hanukkah celebrations with me. My other best friend Molly has Christopagan leanings. None of them are Jewish, yet each one qualifies as what we call a mensch—a solid, trustworthy, decent human being. Their goodness stands on its own.

This approach comes from the tradition itself. You don't need Jewish rituals or identity to live ethically or connect with something bigger. The covenant is specific, not universal in a "join or burn" way. That leaves room for everyone else's paths without diminishing them.

_____

The Weird Tokenization from Evangelical Christians

Since converting, I've had some eye-opening run-ins with evangelical Christians. In the part of the Midwest where I live, Jews are rare. Spotting my Star of David often triggers this unicorn reaction. Suddenly they're extra eager to witness to me, pouring on the effort like they've found a rare collectible. They don't know I grew up in that world, was "born-again" myself, and walked away from Christianity for good at age 19-20.

The whole "G-d's chosen people" dynamic gets extra strange here. Many Christians see themselves as the successors to ancient Israel, the "new Israel" in a spiritual sense, having inherited the promises. Yet when they meet an actual Jew, that doesn't stop them from trying harder to convert us than they do with other Gentiles. It's like we're simultaneously holy relics from the Bible and tragically misguided souls barreling toward a special hell for rejecting Christ. As a convert, I knew I'd signed up for both antisemitism and this kind of tokenization, but it still feels deeply weird every time. One minute you're exotic; the next, you're a project for salvation.

These encounters highlight how outsiders project their own frameworks onto Jewish identity. Christians wrestling with their theology around Israel and the church often don't realize how it lands on actual Jews trying to live our lives. It turns personal faith into a prop in someone else's narrative. I appreciate genuine curiosity and interfaith dialogue, but the hard sell combined with that relic treatment gets exhausting.

_____

What "G-d's Chosen People" Actually Means

​Here's the core of it. I'm a henotheist more than a monotheist. The commandment "Thou shalt have no other gods before me" doesn't erase the existence of other gods. It points to Hashem as one particular deity with a specific covenant involving one particular people. Reform Judaism, the branch I joined, holds that the past gets a vote but not a veto. Traditions evolve over millennia while keeping core obligations for those who identify as observant. Being Jewish isn't only a religion—it's a tribal identity, a peoplehood that has survived thousands of years of exile, pogroms, and genocide.

My own belief wavers some days. There are times I feel certain a Higher Power exists, others when I wonder if it's advanced alien intelligences or something else entirely, and days when doubt takes over. I stepped into Judaism because a people who kept their identity intact through relentless shattering spoke directly to my own experience with PTSD. After decades of self-loathing, addiction, and my life falling apart, this tradition offered a framework for healing and stability. The resilience of the Jewish people resonates with someone whose personal history feels like repeated wreckage.

So what does chosen mean? Hashem is the god for this people. If we take up the covenant, we receive blessings tied to it. Judaism accepts converts—I'm living proof—but it doesn't push conversion as necessary for goodness, divine connection, or dodging judgment. In fact, the tradition often discourages converts. Our people have seen some shit and continue facing serious threats. Converting has always been hard mode, even Reform, and post-October 7 it's even tougher between more shuls being less open to visitors in the wake of increasing violence against synagogues, and additionally tough if you're vocal against Israel's actions in Palestine.

We are not superior. We have a tribal deity and the obligations that come with that relationship—to Hashem, to each other, and to the ethical demands of the tradition. That's the extent of it. The covenant is particular, not a claim of cosmic dominance. And yes, people can join the tribe, as I did. It requires study, commitment, and embracing both the beauty and the baggage.

This understanding doesn't justify occupation or abuse. It doesn't license treating Palestinians or anyone else as lesser. The Torah's emphasis on justice for the stranger undercuts any such twisting. For those of us who support a free Palestine, the chosen concept sits alongside calls for accountability and equality. It never meant permission to dominate.

Jewish life, at its best, balances particular obligations with universal ethics. We light candles on Shabbat, argue over texts, share meals, mourn losses, and celebrate survival. The "chosen" part is about stepping into a specific relationship with all its responsibilities, not about ranking humanity. Outsiders who weaponize the phrase to smear Jews or justify hatred miss this entirely. And Jews who distort it into supremacy also miss the point.

My Gentile friends, the good humans across faiths in my life—they prove daily that goodness transcends any one covenant. Judaism gives me structure, history, and healing without requiring me to diminish anyone else's path. That's the reality behind the phrase that gets so twisted in political fights and online sludge. "G-d's chosen people" is about a relationship, a tribe, and a set of duties. Nothing more, nothing less. If you're coming at this from outside, I hope this clears some fog. We're just people doing our best with an ancient inheritance, same as anyone else trying to make sense of this messy world.